Angel Griffin was ready.
As a young volunteer doula, she had gotten the call that one of her clients was on her way to the hospital to give birth. It was a cheerful occasion, a celebration of the beginning of life. Griffin joined the mother to offer support during labor.
But then, tragedy struck.
The woman gave birth to a stillborn baby, turning what should have been the mother’s happiest moment into her most horrible.
ven know how to explain that,†Griffin said. “I don’t have words for that experience.
Griffin was left searching for answers. What started as her client’s 38-week healthy pregnancy morphed into unmitigated disaster. After taking time to process the event, she realized there were warning signs that went ignored for too long, both by her and by the woman’s doctor.
Griffin said she believes her African-American client’s situation is indicative of a larger problem in the United States. The quality of maternal healthcare is highly segmented by race and socioeconomic status, with lower-income African-American women at the lowest end of the spectrum. Indeed, according to data from the Center for American Progress, African-American women are three times more likely to die in childbirth than white women, and African-American infants are twice as likely to die than white infants.
Experts in the maternal health field attest that the causes of this disparity are complex and numerous, yet most agree there is one underlying current driving the crisis: racism.
Roots of the Maternal Health Problem
Racism in America is not new, and racial inequities in the city of Chicago are a microcosm of the problems minorities face around the country today.
Chicago remains one of the most segregated cities in the country, with 2016 census data showing the city ranks third, after Milwaukee and New York, based on race breakdowns by neighborhood.
In addition, Chicago has a long history of housing discrimination, or “redlining,†stemming from realty practices in the twentieth century that left much of the South Side financially deprived. The effects are still felt today in areas such as education, crime and access to resources.
All of these factors have combined to create a situation where low-income and minority mothers are left at a disadvantage when seeking and receiving a higher quality of care.
“There’s a rather extensive body of research supporting the reality that the medical system providers don’t take black women’s pain as seriously as they take the pain of women of other races,†said Brielle Treece Osting, director of the Maternal and Infant Mortality Initiative at EverThrive Illinois.
Treece Osting explained that a stereotype of black women as being “tougher†or more able to withstand pain leads to a lower standard of care from medical professionals than is afforded to white mothers, further increasing the disparity.
Volunteer doula Angel Griffin talks about the history of the relationship between race and maternal care.
Moreover, chronic stress resulting from the experience of being black in America — the housing instability, financial insecurity and proximity to violence to which African Americans are often subjected — can take a toll on a woman’s pregnancy, according to Dr. Morgan Madison of the PCC Community Wellness Center.
Recognizing that the chronic levels of stress that women of color are exposed to in America can have a negative outcome on your health, even if you are college-educated, even if you’re not struggling financially, is a wake-up call that racism plays a huge part on people’s health,†Madison said.
As proof, Madison and many others pointed to the recent post-birth complications encountered by tennis star Serena Williams, who wrote that she nearly died because of blood clots and a hematoma suffered after the birth of her daughter. Although Williams did not lack access to medical or financial resources, she still ran into the same problems many other black women do.
“If you can imagine someone like Serena Williams, a well-known celebrity, high socioeconomic status, who says, 'I have a problem,' and is not listened to, compare that to the woman who does not have any of those resources,†Griffin said.
Despite awareness of these issues, efforts to combat them have yet to find widespread success. In the meantime, black women’s wellbeing is declining while their mortality rates are on the rise.
Barriers to Quality Maternal Care
The largest obstacle for low-income mothers to quality maternal care is money.
Many more personal pregnancy services, such as midwives and doulas, who provide the mother advice and support throughout the birthing process, are mostly only attainable by those who can afford them.
At Chicago Family Doulas, services can cost upwards of $1,100, according to Director Anna Rodney, who explained that doulas at other organizations might cost over twice as much. Doulas are also not considered a medical expense, meaning insurance is unlikely to cover the fee.
Such prices can be prohibitive for families with less disposable income, relegating them to hospitals, where doctors may not prioritize a mother’s comfort or wishes.
“As people in America, we think that our doctor is right,†said Rebecca Nguyen, owner of Chicago Family Picnic, which offers classes and resources to new moms. “Unfortunately, a lot of [obstetricians] tell women, ‘This is the way we should go because it’s easier for them,’ and end up affecting women low in socioeconomic status and women of color more often.â€
In many low-income communities, a hospital may be the only resource available, and expecting mothers are often not offered information about other options, including birthing centers or giving birth at home under the supervision of a midwife.
The lack of awareness and access to resources creates a cycle that increasingly puts black mothers at risk of unsatisfying birth experiences or even health problems.
“If I went to a birth every single day for the rest of my life, ultimately nothing would change about the system,†said former doula Cindy San Miguel. “The hospitals and medical systems these women are going into would stay the same, and that was very frustrating for me.â€
Possible Solutions
However, solutions are being actively proposed and developed to combat the maternal mortality epidemic. Some hospitals and wellness centers, including Illinois Masonic and Swedish Covenant, have opened clinics in underserved communities, such as Pilsen, to allow pregnant women to seek midwife services more locally. Chicago Volunteer Doulas also offers free doula services to anyone who requests one across the city.
But there is still a lack of access to additional resources among mothers in low-income and minority communities. Birthing centers and informational classes may be impractical for such women to reach, whether because of location or cost. Advice on breastfeeding or infant care can be scarce, and many moms are not even aware of the doula and support services available to them.
Griffin insists the best way to achieve progress is through a grassroots approach.
“You have to go in, build relationships, build trust, see what the community wants,†she said. “See what those people need, and work with them to address those things.â€
Madison agrees that the most effective strategy is one that is created and implemented collectively.
“It’s important to reframe the way that [healthcare providers] communicate with individuals. It can be as simple as saying, ‘I’m listening to you.’â€
Although public health professionals are working to recalibrate the way they approach lower-income communities, the solution is evidently more deep-rooted.
“I think it’s impossible to solve this crisis in a meaningful way without confronting and dismantling the systemic white supremacy that permeates culture in the United States,†said Treece Osting. “There’s almost no better proof about the impact of racism in our country than this crisis.â€